Is it just me or is Alex Pettyfer the most wanted actor to play the on-screen roles of popular characters featured in YA novels? It’s not just me. As I’m sure you’ve heard Alex has already scored the role in the screen adaptation of YA novel I am Number Four. He’s also been dubbed the ideal leading man for Jace in the up-coming City of Bones movie and Peeta in The Hunger Games.
Perhaps it’s because he’s attractive. Incredibly attractive. When describingAlex to my boyfriend I said, “He’s the male version of Brooklyn Decker.” He got it. Even when they ‘ugly him up’ in Beastly, he still manages to be the most attractive male cast member (no offense, Neil Patrick Harris).

Or maybe it’s because he’s British and YA novels-turned movies seem to always cast a British lead. Alex fits nicely into the category of British actor-turned YA heartthrob, like the late Robert Pattinson. Not late as in dead, but late as in, he’s no longer in style. I realized he was officially out of style when I heard teenage girls booing him at the theater during the Water for Elephants preview – to which I wanted to turn around and tell them that I hoped Rob Pattinson’s appearance on screen wouldn’t deter them from reading the book where they could picture Alex Pettyfer as the lead if they liked.
Others in this category include the boys…er…men of Harry Potter. I mean, Daniel Radcliffe is a heartthrob, isn’t he? Didn’t people pay good money to see him strip on Broadway? And Martin Scorsese hailed Rupert Grint the next Leonardo DiCaprio – and Leonardo DiCaprio DEFINED heartthrob when I was a teenager.
So, who else should Alex embody? Perhaps Ky in Matched (when it inevitably gets optioned – if it hasn’t already) or Will in Clockwork Angel (which I want to see in movie form ASAP). May I point out that Will would actually require Alex to use that pretty British accent of his? Although he’d have to die his hair black to truly personify Will. But hey - while he’s walking around with black hair, he could play Adam from If I Stay.
I’m cool with casting him as every YA male lead for the next five years until he’s officially “too old” and we discover the next Brit who will embody our YA heroes.
Who ELSE would you like to see him portray?